Honest value of a 1923 tail on the O

[chgolaw1]

Just gathering opinions on the value of a PCGS MS 64 1923-1C Tail on the O?

[knscoin]

I maybe wrong 750.00 to 900.00 . The price has come down with more on the market and being attributed by TPG .

[chgolaw1]

Thanks Kevin. I figured tops of about $675. I saw one on eBay for $1725, but seller wouldn’t budge under $1700. It is a very late die state though.

[colwillys]

I have one 1923-P VAM 1C in my guide book sold $360 MS 63 4-2-23 . I was nice sold in grapevine TX . small show .
I have a LDS VAM 1C ANACS MS 64 in my collection and i to would ask $1725 . NOT FOR SALE .
Price is what someone will pay . My problem is i buy and DO NOT SELL .

[chgolaw1]

Same here Tom. I don’t sell. Do you happen to know the die state of the one that sold? Also what die states are the ones you have? If you have photos I would appreciate that. Thanks Dom

[knscoin]

PCGS MS 64 sold for 930.00 0n 7-22-22 David Lawrence

[chgolaw1]

Kevin do you know if you can look them up like on HA?

[chgolaw1]

Thanks anyway Kevin I looked it up on their archives. It’s a LDS, but not the latest

[colwillys]

Hi Dom
The VAM 1C sold in April was Mid die state . If the deal fell through i would have bought the coin .
Photos of my 2 coins AU 58 VLDS MS 64 LDS . my opp . Tell me what you think .

Image122.jpg (97.97 KiB) Viewed 1486 times

Image123.jpg (156.37 KiB) Viewed 1486 times

Image124.jpg (93.07 KiB) Viewed 1486 times

Image125.jpg (146.31 KiB) Viewed 1486 times

[chgolaw1]

Tom thats a beautiful die stage on that 58. Nice photo. Thanks again Dom

[knscoin]

up-date one sold last weekend at Stacks Bowers Auction PCGS Holder MS 64 LDS $780.00

[chgolaw1]

Once again everything should based on the die state. I have seen so many claiming LDS and they are lucky to rate a mid dies state. This is the reason the price is so cheap. I will try to look it up and compare the die states with Tom’s and mine. Once before we talked about the Top Pops in the SSDC Registrations. For the grades are high, but the die state should also be part of the judging process. I guess that’s the way it would work in a perfect world.

[knscoin]

Please judge for yourself . if you consider Toms are a LDS so is the one that just sold .
That just my opinion . Check Stacks Bowers auction
,Have a Blessed Day , Keith

[chgolaw1]

Keith do you have a link for the one that just sold on Stacks and Bowers? As far as Tom’s go the AU58 is a LDS. The MS64 is not. I am in the process of doing study for EDS TO ULDS. Thanks Dom

[knscoin]

It www.StacksBower.com then go to archive . Aug 23 is the date the auction ended .
I hope that helps the coin is more like the 64 that Tom has posted

[colwillys]

Now lets not go to fast Mid die state LDS VLDS ULDS . I got my letters out from LVA . This 1923-P VAM 1C2 is said
to be LDS per LVA . Collar clash #2 UN of UNITED . One more point gouge at last Tara Ray 2/3 the way up . All
3 of my coins have this gouge or metal . Could be good pick up point .

Image191.jpg (110.64 KiB) Viewed 901 times

Image192.jpg (103.3 KiB) Viewed 901 times

Image193.jpg (118.95 KiB) Viewed 901 times

[colwillys]

Alll 3 have the same die file lines on REV Under O in DOLLAR and near olive leaves .

[knscoin]

The Bigger the Die Break under the O that makes the Tail
The better it is .

[chgolaw1]

Keith thanks. I checked out the stacks auction. The coin is in deed a LDS, but not an ULDS When I put my study together I will post the results. The coin I have is a ULDS.

[chgolaw1]

I also have a ULDS of the 1922-2a Earring.