OT: guess the Buffalo grade (revealed!)

[DHalladay]

Seller's pixs were too small, so this is all I have to work with. It's in a straight graded holder, so don't be imagining stuff.

1916-D obv copy.jpg (339.86 KiB) Viewed 1883 times

1916-D rev copy.jpg (329.31 KiB) Viewed 1883 times

[JASONKFLO]

Maybe AU-50? Hard to see well so I may be out in Left Field.

[Vam-mysterio]

Au53

[JohnGoldsmith]

It's a trick, this guy pulls thus stuff when the grade is all wrong. MS61

[blh74]

35-40

[Mike7E]

VF-20 much of horn visible

[vamnuke]

AU 58

[Longstrider]

XF 45.

[Longstrider]

Wife says AU 58. First she said a high VG so ???

[raynat3]

MS60

[sheatown1]

Probably an xf-45 but I'd say MS-62. Some weird grades on some slab companies to get newbies money.

[fogie]

I call it AU50 but think it is stabbed VF

[messydesk]

I see luster, but 16-D isn't one of the weak strike dates. XF45?

[DHalladay]

Get your guesses in, I'll post the holder's obverse tonight.

[DarksideVAM]

AU55

[hairfield1]

MS-61

[VamHelsing]

AU?

[iwillbenice]

EF-40.

[collectinsince65]

ef40

[lioncutter]

MS 65 even though it's not.