VAMWorld 2.0

Greysheet is clueless in this instance on a scale that is beyond staggering.

It is the responsibility of submitters to familiarize themselves with, and fully understand, which VAMs a grading service does and does not attribute. Period.

Looks like mechanical (strike) doubling.

lured_in_again wrote: ↑

Mon Oct 16, 2023 3:32 am

Maybe just me, but the minor scuff marks appear to match up on the photos. Looks to be same coin in my opinion....

You know... I have to agree!
Marks under the E, L, BU, S, U, M all match.

OK folks. First, as points of reference, here are some October 2023 Greysheet prices to keep in mind: AU58 – $45 MS62 – $70 MS63 – $200 MS64 – $405 MS65 – $485 MS66 – $750 MS67 – $16,000 My neck is sore from shaking it side to side as I look at this coin and grapple with these thoughts: – This has t...

Straight graded by NGC.
I will post the results Sunday night.
Have fun... and thanks for playing.

I think this is a 1936-D Buffalo RPM-002 (FS-502). Can anyone confirm or correct?

I recently got smoked on a 1921-D VAM 3A in PCGS 64 CAC in a GC auction. It sold for $1150 with the vig, which is strong 66 money for a 21-D. I have a hard time believing that the nasty rattler with a green sticker on it accounted for all that premium, but the holder market is sufficiently bizarre ...

http://ec2-13-58-222-16.us-east-2.compu ... -D_VAM-8B1

The gouges next to the bow are secondary PUPs. The HUGE horizontal gouges just above the arrows in the upper tail feathers are the key diagnostic for this VAM.

With all filled letter varieties the degree of filling is incredibly important, so a photo of your coin would be exceedingly helpful.

I once bought a PCGS VF30 1903-S on eBay for less than Greysheet that had crappy photos and pretty significant toning on both sides. When it showed up in the mail it turned out, much to my surprise, to be a Micro-S. I thought it was undergraded so I sent it in for regrade, and it came back VF35. Dou...

Thank you Brent!

Now here are three more obverse polishing lines:

I will get this taken care of! (But my photo posting wiz @fogie is on the road with his laptop, so it may take a few days.)

Uncle:

Yes... YES!
Thank you VERY much!!

And boy does the attribution page need some more photos.

Lots of scribbles on this EDS-ish coin, but I can't find a match in the scribbles guide. Had to take a 2nd photo with a slightly ifferent light source angle to better show the shallow "arch" gouge indicated by the yellow arrow: 1921-D #1 scribbles1.jpg There are a few nice polishing lines on the obv...

Definitely a 44A.

John:
The three PCGS-graded Micro-O dates that are labeled 4, 5 and 3 could actually be something else, right?

Thanks Tom and John. Looks like I still need 2 of the 4... 3BQ2 and 3BQ4.

Trying hard to figure out what I have now between 4 coins, but 3BQ4 seems to be the only one I'm confident about ruling out. I have 2 coins with reverse file lines like crazy (which I had called VAM 81). Both have a diagonal line through the opening in D (along with cracks in the wreath and left rib...