VAMWorld 2.0

fogie wrote: ↑

Mon Jan 30, 2023 7:48 pm

something begins to smell funny....

And it it has been forever.
So many wild stories.
Never any photos.
Never any corroboration.
Endless excuses.

The huge problem is, the 1921-D Die Crack Break Guide is horribly not up to date. Only 77 different VAMs are represented in it, out of the 228 that currently exist.

I have no prices in my database for VAM 1B3 (which is scarce)... I only have prices for 1B3A (which is ultra-rare). I am skeptical about which VAM the cheapest two sales in the list below actually were, because the prices weren't appropriate: 1921-S 1B3A 62 PCGS Aug-12 H $3,055 1921-S 1B3A 55 ANACS ...

This is what's known as hijacking a thread.
Very inconsiderate.

... for the best (and very unexpected) award 'plaque' ever. I didn't attend the recent FUN show and VAM Thing meeting, so it was a huge surprise when I received the email about this: 2022 SSDC Set Award.jpg The picture that was sent doesn't begin to compare to how wonderful it is in hand, and I can'...

small lines in left wing.jpg The first scribbles photo shows something I have never seen before. Some of the little diagonal gouges indicated across the bottom show up individually somewhat regularly on both 1921-Ps and Ds (especially #1, #2, #5 and #8), but never all together and in such an appare...

I received my JOH-22 and here's what I found:

It is VAM 3.

Fascinating to learn this!
I knew the U.S. sold a LOT of silver to Britain during WWI for geopolitical reasons in India, but did not know it was used to make coins. We almost need to consider the 1919 Rupee for honorary status in the Morgan Dollar set.

Your die cracks + feed finger lines tells me it's 1CL2.
Pretty coin.

Feed finger gouges 'wandered' a bit during the course of their lives; photos on the attribution pages aren't a must match exactly proposition.

I know it's an esoteric question, but with all the excellent cracks on both sides I'm hoping maybe someone has already sent one to @vampicker or @messydesk for evaluation.

He is just following the new DC guideline of posting it here for more eyes to evaluate first, as opposed to simply sending it to @vampicker or @messydesk where it might slow things down in their lives. I say bravo for following directions.

Thanks Lee!
They have been added.

Rotation alone does not make for a VAM. Other factors specify which VAM it is; rotation is just a bonus.

VamHelsing wrote: ↑

Fri Jan 20, 2023 7:10 pm

One of my favorites!!

Same here!
Congrats!!

I'm still trying to find one.

I'd just be guessing, and doubt that would be particularly helpful at this point. At a minimum, I'd want to see more examples for some context. Do these occur on other die pairs? In other series? Thanks John. I haven't seen them on other die pairs or in other series... just on VAM 1G. But it is on ...

colwillys wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 19, 2023 9:56 pm

This is for Dennis. Broadstrike partials collar & Double strike. RAW , will not holder do to hiding RIM

Nice!

Part way down the attribution page for 1921-D VAM 1G http://ec2-13-58-222-16.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com/wiki/1921-D_VAM-1G is a photo of strange 'dents' under the denticles above IBU on the obverse, and a note that says: "George Powell made a cool find in July 2004. Look closely at the holes be...